Taxonomic Swap 138835 (Submetido em 09-02-2024)

See discussion here https://www.inaturalist.org/flags/646596

P.royenii sensu stricto was given to Puerto Rico and VI Pilosocereus but there are hundreds of observations identified as such all over the Neotropics and the Caribbean. There have never been any P.royenii outside the Puerto Rican Bank (when it was a valid species), it is also now as a syn. of P.polygonus it is only restricted to a single island (Hispaniola). Puerto Rican Bank Pilosocereus are now P.armatus.

See:
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/334637489_Revision_of_Pilosocereus_Cactaceae_in_the_Caribbean_and_northern_Andean_region
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/354247877_Cactaceae_at_Caryophyllalesorg_-_a_dynamic_online_species-level_taxonomic_backbone_for_the_family

desconhecido
Adicionado(s) por stevemaldonadosilvestrini em 04 de fevereiro de 2024, 10:19 PM | Committed by stevemaldonadosilvestrini on 09 de fevereiro de 2024
replaced with

Comentários

I do not agree with the above information, P. royenii seems to have a more or less less blue for sort of aqua on PR. A very blue form on Virgin Islands. Also don't agree combining polygonus with royenii.

Publicado por brcacti 3 meses antes

@brcacti We are not combining P.royenii with P.polygonus here but rather making all P.royenii = Pilosocereus. I implore you to read the articles cited to understand why this change is happening, it has little to do with morphological characters and more to do with taxonomic messes. The material of the Puerto Rican Bank is now names Pilosocereus armatus. P.royenii is now a synonym of P.polygonus as it preceded the naming of Puerto Rican Bank material with said name. Furthermore P.royenii sensu lato was strictly a PR Bank species before, and here you can see how they have named columnar cacti from all over the Neotropics with that name, a crass error.

Publicado por stevemaldonadosil... 3 meses antes

I really don't see any need for all this "confusion". I understand it all as it currently is and don't understand why you or others would be confused. I think this is needless confusion.

Publicado por brcacti 3 meses antes

I implore you to read the papers cited for the change to understand. iNat follows POWO KEW taxonomy and in there P.royenii is a synonym of P.polygonus.

Publicado por stevemaldonadosil... 3 meses antes

Adicionar um Comentário

Iniciar Sessão ou Registar-se to add comments